How AI Can Help Negotiate Higher Payer Rates, with Brace Health
Private Practice Owners ClubOctober 27, 202600:38:1234.98 MB

How AI Can Help Negotiate Higher Payer Rates, with Brace Health

Most private practice owners assume insurance companies won't negotiate. But what if you could increase your reimbursement rates with the right strategy, the right argument, and the right person?


In this episode of the Private Practice Owners Club, Nathan Shields sits down with David O'Hara of Brace Health to break down how private practice owners can negotiate better payer rates and stop leaving money on the table.


David shares what they've learned from hundreds of payer negotiations, including what payers actually care about, how to build leverage, how AI can identify opportunities, and why finding the right person inside an insurance company can make all the difference.


In this episode, you'll learn:


  • Why some practices are successfully getting 5–10%+ rate increases
  • How an additional $5 per visit can translate into significant annual revenue
  • Why the highest-paying payers may actually be more willing to negotiate
  • What insurance companies actually care about when negotiating rates
  • Why network adequacy can give practices leverage
  • How to use local market data to strengthen your negotiation
  • How AI can identify geographic and specialty-specific opportunities
  • Why simply telling payers that your costs have increased may not be enough
  • Why you should focus your negotiation on specific rate increases
  • How to determine what to ask for in a payer negotiation
  • Why asking for a larger increase can sometimes be more effective
  • How to find the right network or contracting manager
  • Why some negotiations require persistent follow-up
  • What happened after one practice sent 11 follow-up emails
  • How building relationships with payer representatives can improve negotiations
  • How successful negotiations can create immediate improvements to your bottom line
  • Why negotiating reimbursement rates can also be a form of advocacy for the PT industry
  • What practice owners should know before starting the negotiation process


Payer negotiations don't have to be complicated or adversarial. With the right strategy, preparation, and persistence, practice owners can create more leverage and potentially improve reimbursement.


If you're a private practice owner who wants to stop accepting low reimbursement rates and learn how to approach payer negotiations strategically, this episode is for you.


Want to talk about how we can help you with your PT business, or have a question you want to ask? Book a call with Nathan - https://calendly.com/ptoclub/discoverycall


Love the show? Subscribe, rate, review, and share! https://ptoclub.com/

[00:00:00] The negotiations, it really started about a year ago, but it really picked up about four to six months ago. And we've got several hundred under our belt now. Welcome to the Private Practice Owners Club. Your hosts and coaches, Nathan Shields scaled his practice and exited for millions, while Adam Robin went from working 60 hours a week in one clinic to scaling to multiple clinics while working less than four hours per week remotely.

[00:00:26] This podcast is meant to share with you exactly how they did it and how you can build a business that supports the lifestyle that you truly desire. And don't forget to join the Private Practice Owners Club community on Facebook, where we are obsessed with providing even more resources that help owners just like you win the game of private practice. Hey, it's Nathan. Quick heads up for all the private practice owners who are listening.

[00:00:55] If you've been listening to the podcast for a while, you know that it took me at least 10 years of grinding in my own clinics before I finally figured out how to scale and sell my four practices for seven figures and about three times the national average. The biggest shift wasn't some secret marketing hack. It was how I thought about profit systems and actually my role as the owner.

[00:01:19] That's exactly what we're going to be working on together with you at the High Performance Practice Conference this fall in San Antonio, Texas. From October 15th through 17th, Adam Robin and I are hosting a three-day hands-on event for PT, OT, speech, mental health, PEDS, pelvic floor, and medical practice owners who want to build clinics that are profitable, scalable, and best of all, don't depend on them 24-7.

[00:01:47] We'll dig into simple profit and KPI frameworks, real leadership and culture work, and practical systems you can take home and plug in with your team. So if you're doing roughly six to seven low figures a year and you want your clinic to feel more like a real business and less like a job slash cage, I'd love to see you there. Frankly, I'd love to see you bring your leadership teams as well because we will have breakout sessions for them too. You can get all the details and grab your seat at the link in the show notes.

[00:02:16] All right, let's get into today's episode. Hello and welcome to the Private Practice Owners Club. I am your host, Nathan Shields. And today I have with me David O'Hara of Brace Health, an AI native billing services company. And David and I have been working a little bit together, a new free payer negotiations program. Since we just talked about it recently with Adam on the call, I thought I'd bring on David and talk about it as well.

[00:02:44] But first of all, David, thanks for joining. Thank you for having me today, Nathan. Excited to be here. Yeah. Well, I'd love your perspective because you've been doing some payer negotiations with PT companies. Have you been working with others besides PT? PT, OT, speech, dietician. I'm in the four so far. Nice. All right. I am chiropractic actually, five. Oh, nice. Yeah. Cool. Well, tell me, you've had some experience. You've been doing it for how long? A little under a year?

[00:03:13] The negotiations, it really started about a year ago, but it really picked up about four to six months ago. And we've got several hundred under our belt now. So excited to share a little bit about what's working, what's not working. Well, tell me right off the bat. So I'm inclined just to contextualize this. And if you listen to the previous episode that Adam and I did about increasing profitability and possibly negotiating with payers, I'm a little bit more inclined to really drop the lowest payers. And we know who those chronically are.

[00:03:41] I think sometimes the time and effort that it takes to get an extra two, three, or $5 per visit isn't necessarily worth it, nor does it make up for some of the administrative headaches that those lower payers can put you up against. So you tell me from your perspective now, you are the boots on the ground. You've done this a number of times, like you said. Is it worth it? Are you seeing it being worth an owner's time to go through the process of asking for more money from these insurance companies?

[00:04:10] Yeah, the short answer is yes. And I don't disagree with what you're suggesting. So we've done a hundred of these negotiations, mostly for practices in the one to five location mix. So this is not the large enterprises. These are for the smaller practices. And about 35 percent of the practices we work with are able to get at least one rate increase. That's usually in like the five to 10 percent range. So that's the first point of is it going to fundamentally change the economics?

[00:04:38] Unlikely, given what Nathan has been suggesting. But it can be meaningful. You can imagine, you know, five extra dollars, 200 visits a month. That's 15K a year. That can be from, you know, just one email. So it is worth it. And sometimes it's a little more than one email. But it is worth it. And it is working. Yeah. If people want to check out some of the specifics, they can go to bracehealth.com slash Nathan. B-R-A-C-E health dot com slash Nathan. N-A-T-H-A-N.

[00:05:05] To see what some of the other testimonials might have to say and what is all offered. And even get on the wait list to see if they can help you out. So check that out so you get more details there. What I'm wondering though, or where would you recommend owners start then? If you and I are both in agreement that maybe some of those little pairs you just don't mess with. Are you looking at some of the pairs that have a higher census in the clinic? Are those the ones you recommend initially?

[00:05:32] Or do you start just simply with a lower payer and work your way up? So what's sort of counterintuitive is an interesting insight that we found early on is that some of the highest paying payers are often the ones most willing to negotiate. And so I would not limit, I think a lot of times it's like, well, let me start with the low payers and then go to the high payers. I would actually more start on what payers matter most to you in terms of patient volumes. Because that's where you're going to get your biggest bang for the buck. And there's some that I would immediately take off the list.

[00:06:00] Obviously, Medicare, state Medicaid. If you don't own the contract, like if there's some central body, you doing individual negotiating is not going to do anything. But a lot of the commercials, a lot of the workers comp, we've had wins with some of the large nationals, a lot of the smaller regionals. So it starts, I think, with the payer mix in terms of where to spend the time. And then it's going into, well, what do they actually care about? Which we can talk about more, but I think it's starting with which payers matter the most for your practice.

[00:06:29] Well, I guess that is the question. What moves the needle with some of these payers for them to actually being willing to negotiate with you? Have you seen certain talking points that really make a difference and sway them one way or another? And what might those be? Yeah, that's basically where this started. We talked to a number of owners. It was something like less than 20% of them had ever tried. And the answer was, one, I don't know what to say. Two, I don't know who to say it to. And three, it's probably not worth my time to figure that out.

[00:06:59] So we first, to start this off, we did a bunch of research on what payers care about. Read white papers, watch YouTube videos, had AI ingest all of this. And then we actually brought this to a handful of practices who had successfully negotiated, especially some of the larger ones. And then we brought it to payers directly. And we created this sort of framework that we now have been using. The first set of negotiations, we did 10 and four had increases. And so we said, you know, maybe there is something here that we should get to. Now, I'll share like our perspective on it.

[00:07:28] But major caveat is, you know, we are new to this. We've only been doing this for a year. We don't consider ourselves like the end-all, be-all experts. Well, you have a lot more experience than most everyone that's listening. We do have a few hundred, you know, instances that we can start to draw some patterns from. And what you're also going to hear is I'm very, I'll come across as sort of cynical and negative about payers, but I hope it comes across mostly as realistic. But at the highest level, what payers deal in is incentives and leverage.

[00:07:56] Incentives is what does the payer care about? And leverage is what can you credibly do or credibly threaten to do that impacts what the payers care about. What a lot of practices start with is their own margin pressure, staffing costs, inflation, the long-term value of PT, arguments that sort of are like, we deserve more. That's all true. But this doesn't actually influence payers on their own. You have to ask, what do payers actually care about? And it's really two things. One is network adequacy.

[00:08:27] Employers are the payer's real customer. Employers judge their plans based on access. Can my employees access care when they need it? When that access breaks down, payers feel pressure. And that's what creates complaints, regulatory scrutiny, et cetera. We've seen this over the last five years in mental health. There was a huge demand from employees saying, hey, to their employers, I need access to mental health. It gave mental health providers lots of leverage and they were able to secure much higher rates. So number one, it's about network adequacy.

[00:08:55] Talk about why that's a hard argument to make because of what they believe. But that's sort of the first theme. And the second one is near-term cost control. And the surprising statistic is that the average commercially insured member stays on their plan for less than 24 months. So if you try to make an argument to a payer that, hey, I can reduce costs in a three to five year time period, they say, that doesn't really help me because these members are going to kind of churn before that happens. And so we stem all of our arguments into one of those two.

[00:09:24] Either you're going to solve employer complaints and a network adequacy problem, or you're going to immediately reduce sort of near-term costs. And I can sort of describe what are the arguments that work within each of those if you want to go into that. I do want to go into that. Let me ask one more question because I know there's plenty of studies that show how getting physical therapy early on, especially in musculoskeletal cases, and I can't speak to the same for OT and speech. So I'm sorry, guys who are listening.

[00:09:49] But in the PT world, how it saves the healthcare dollar the sooner the patient gets in for physical therapy instead of going through the primary care route. Does that carry any weight at all? Do they care? Maybe they don't. Have you tried that? What have you found? Yeah. Again, just one perspective here. They know that. There are so many studies out there. So when you just reiterate that point to them, it's like this isn't new information for the strategy folks at these organizations. They know that information.

[00:10:18] What's unique is your specific network importance. And that's like more local, regional, niche, specialty specific that you can make an argument about. Or it's your ability to impact their near-term costs. And that comes down to like other care pathways that are going to be more expensive that patients will opt into if you are not in network with them. And so we try to make it more localized, specific to the practice because there's lots of outcomes data.

[00:10:47] And it shows all of the impact it can have on the healthcare system more broadly. We know that. But that's not, from our experience, that's not what is going to get the attention of that network manager whose job is just make sure I have enough network adequacy so I don't get yelled at by my boss when we lose an employer contract because I haven't managed the network well enough. Right, right.

[00:11:06] So tell me how you leverage AI to help owners with the network adequacy problem and also how it improves financial outcomes for the benefit of the payer. Absolutely. So on the network adequacy side, unfortunately, most payers believe they have enough PT. So the job is to prove that they don't without you. And so the general positioning is like if we left your network, some of your members would lose critical access to care.

[00:11:35] So the arguments that we typically try to make are geographic scarcity. We're the only one in this zip code or this town, usually some sort of clinical specialization. The one that seems to get the most traction right now is pediatric, pelvic, and neuro. Those are the ones that generally get reactions. Now, operational access is also a form of network adequacy where maybe you're in an area that has a lot of night shift workers and you're open 5 to 8 a.m.

[00:12:02] That's a form of access that folks would lose if you weren't there. And so that's partially what the – many practice owners know this argument already. They know their local networks. You don't necessarily need the AI. What the AI allows us to do is we go on Google Maps and we look at what are all the practices nearby and what's unique about what you're doing, where is their traffic, and then what is that best argument from a network adequacy perspective. And we actually do the same thing on the near-term cost increases.

[00:12:31] We're going to look, are there local hospitals that if – or hospital-affiliated groups that if you went out of network, that's where patients are going to go? And not only we all know that PT visits are two to four times more expensive when they go to a hospital or a hospital-affiliated practice, but health system care also pulls in imaging, specialist referrals, diagnostics, sometimes earlier unnecessarily. A single MRI is six to ten PT visits.

[00:12:56] So we try to make that case of like, hey, look, patients driving along this road. If we are out of network, they're going to take a left at this turn and they're going right to this hospital group and that's where you're going to start to see your costs really increase. So again, it's trying to use this technology to get really local to this is the value that I bring. Now, you focus on those two things as super important.

[00:13:17] There are the general strains that have been – that most owners have noticed in terms of increase in salaries, especially for providers and the inflationary costs over the past six years especially. Do you still mention those just as like towards the bottom? On top of all this, we still – or do you just leave that out? We add them as credibility to the threat of going out of network. This is why we need to go out of network. It's like, hey, this isn't just a letter. This isn't just a phone call.

[00:13:47] This isn't like – we have actual structural reasons why this is challenging for us. And we also use patient reviews in that same way where we say our patients really love us. Look at our Google reviews. Look at our NPS. And very frustrated to their employer. They might still come to us and use out of network benefits and again be frustrated at their employer. So we try to use those as credibility of it's a real risk that we go out of network as opposed to an argument in itself.

[00:14:16] Very cool. Is there anything else that we're missing? We covered a lot of the details that go into that initial letter. Is there anything else that we're missing that we haven't covered? What I often hear is a lot of debate around what to ask for. And my opinion is it's very tempting to ask for a broad set of changes. Authorizations, expanded visit limits, direct access pilots. These are all great ideas.

[00:14:42] Our experience is that it's best to just ask for rates as a starting point for a couple reasons. One, those other things are more planned design. Planned design takes a lot more time often than rates. It also usually involves multiple decision makers. We're dealing with network managers, contract managers who have a very specific remit, which is manage the network. And they might have one lever to increase rates. Many of them don't.

[00:15:10] So we tell practice owners, hey, this isn't a silver bullet. You might get all rejections. But if they do have that lever, we're going to make that best case on their behalf. But once you start to introduce other asks, it can kind of dilute the communication funnel as well as just you're going to slightly different part of the organization. Doesn't mean as an industry we stop pushing for it. We absolutely should. There's real place for this work.

[00:15:32] But I don't think as an individual practice with limited time and leverage, I'd be pretty honed in on what are the specific rates that I can get. And then if you don't get them, follow Nathan's advice. Let's cut those low pairs. You know the old adage, if you fail to plan, you plan to fail. And as a practice owner, simply winging it is not a growth strategy.

[00:15:57] Imagine instead waking up every single morning knowing exactly what your business priorities are and what will move the needle. That's what real annual strategic planning does for you. Instead of trying to map out your year all by yourself, especially during the busiest quarters, let me help you with it. I'll fly out to your practice individually, helping you on a full day to map out your goals and align you and your team for maximum profitability and success. I only work with a few practice owners a year on a first come first serve basis.

[00:16:26] So if you're serious about making this next year, your most successful yet, shoot me an email at Nathan at PPOClub.com today and I'll get you the details. Well, I'm glad you brought up rates because that was an obvious miss on my point. Yeah, you got to ask for the money. What then determines the ask that you have? And is that part of the support that Brace Health provides?

[00:16:51] Because if you and I both know that most owners listening, I would say don't know their cost per visit. Yep. Just based on my experience. Yep. Most, I'm willing to say 51% at least, don't know their cost per visit. They might know a general range of their reimbursement per visit, but I'm assuming that the program, number one, looks at the financial data to say this is what XYZ insurance is paying you per visit in the past trailing six to 12 months.

[00:17:19] But you also need to know your cost per visit. Do you pick an arbitrary number to shoot for or is that a calculated number that you're asking for when you ask for an increase? I have yet to hear any feedback or have any specific data that would suggest there's a better approach than an arbitrary number. What we generally do is just ask for a large percentage increase. And it's just a mechanism of the ask with the rationale.

[00:17:47] It's sort of like your charges versus the allowed amounts. I see that. It doesn't really matter what you charge. They're going to pay you the allowed amounts. And so we used to put in like smaller asks, 10, 15% asks. And we actually found some payers would match those. So we were like, shoot, that means we didn't ask for enough. So now a lot of times we just come out the gate and say, we need a 50% increase. And we have yet to have someone say, no, because the ask is so high. We haven't had that feedback quite yet.

[00:18:17] So at a minimum, ask for the high aligned with your highest payer. But I also wouldn't constrain yourself to just the highest payer because I would also make an argument that they're underpaying you too. Right. Exactly. And that's a good point because it almost doesn't matter what you throw out there at first. You're just trying to start the conversation. Yeah. And now what flies slightly in the face of everything I've just shared is there also is an argument that what you ask for doesn't matter at all. Like the arguments don't matter.

[00:18:45] And what really matters is who you make the ask to and just making the ask. Now, that was going to be my next question. Like, how do you determine who to send this letter to? You might just think generically the customers or the provider service representative or something. But no, I did an interview a few years ago with Trace Kennamore in Tennessee. It took him three months to find the right person in his regional United Healthcare Administration to talk to.

[00:19:14] And there was one person over United Healthcare for his particular region. Yes. It took him three months to find that person. Yes. We now have that United Healthcare person for every region in the country. But it has taken us so much effort to find we're looking for a network manager, a provider contracting manager, a network development manager. And you usually have to either call or email some generic line. You get forwarded six different times. You get to the wrong person.

[00:19:41] So we've spent an enormous amount of time building this like contact database that we're constantly trimming and improving so that you can know very quickly, like, OK, if you're in this state dealing with this payer, this is who you speak with. And for states that we haven't worked in, we sort of offered as part of this kind of free program with you, Nathan, is like we will actually go out and do that work for you. So we are making phone calls. We are sending emails. We're on LinkedIn doing everything we can to find that person. But it's often very difficult to find that person.

[00:20:10] So that's the one area that I certainly understand why practice owners are not going after because it's like these big monoliths. Like, how am I going to find that individual? It's not easy to negotiate that. That's the one thing I like about your program is you are building out this database. Yeah. And you're into it, but you're still building the database so that you can have all that contact information and a data set behind what they're willing to pay, etc. That makes a difference. Yeah. Across the nation, state by state. Absolutely.

[00:20:39] And once we find that person, I often they're not an adversary. If you can find the right person, they're just a decision maker with a set of incentives and they want to remain employed and do a good job at work. So I often think of it as like, how can you help them promote it? And so a lot of these conversations are actually like they're not necessarily adversarial because you end up finding this person who's responsible for managing the network of physical therapy, rehab therapy in a certain area.

[00:21:09] And you are trying to tell them like, hey, there's something you're missing. Like, let me help make your job better, make you more effective at what you're doing. If you can get to that right person, it's just hard to get there. And then if that doesn't work, we have a series of escalation tactics that we recommend that can be useful or we've seen kind of varying uses of them. So you through the program, you generate the gather all this information, you generate the proper negotiation form and who to send it to. Yeah.

[00:21:36] Owners send this off on their own behalf. You don't do it. Yeah, correct. You just do all this background work for them so that they can just copy and paste and then send it off. Right. But once they do that, two questions, what are the follow ups look like? And then what kind of time frames are you seeing communication finally come through? So they typically start with either an email or a phone call. That's sort of the standard route. And what we encourage is follow ups until you receive a no.

[00:22:06] We had a negotiation recently in the Southeast US took 11 follow up emails to the same individual. No responses for all 11 emails. You went 11. I would have given up after like three. And then they gave a 10% bump. Oh my gosh. It's not that time consuming, you know, to send an email that just says following up, right? Like all you're doing is just putting it at the top of their inbox again. So a couple like tactical pieces.

[00:22:34] Number one, if you get a response, don't take the first offer. If they're willing to give you an increase, they might be willing to give you a higher increase. And we have yet to see someone get their increase taken off the table because they asked for more. If you don't get the increase, what a lot of practices do is they'll say, please send over the paperwork required for us to terminate our in-network agreement. That can like trigger internal routing because it signals that you're more serious about leaving the network. So that's often a common path.

[00:23:02] And then there are more aggressive paths where we have had practices draft letters to patients explaining that they are forced to go out of network because rates are unsustainable and encouraging them to bring that to their HR departments, especially in areas where there's kind of large employers that drive most of it. And then some will even say they're going to bring that to the local media. Now, of course, you don't want to be like overtly threatening to payers. Like that's not the right tone to take. But again, you're thinking about like, what do they care about? What are they worried about?

[00:23:31] And how can I really engage with them on that? Yeah. And so are you seeing, is there a sweet spot as to when negotiations finally become successful or does it vary across the board? I'm assuming it's going to take at least 90 days, but it could extend out to six months, 12 months. Yeah. The uninspiring answer here is it varies. We have a payer in the Northeast that is one email. They'll respond in two days and they'll give you a 25% bump every time. What? That is it.

[00:24:00] We've had 25 plus wins with that pair. We have some pairs that we've been sending follow-up emails for for six months and haven't received a response. I would say if there was an average, probably in the 60 to 90 days. But a lot of that work is typically like finding the right person. So the faster you can get to the right person, the faster we can have it turn around. It's not like hours and hours of work over 60 to 90 days. It's usually just follow-up emails and a few calls to get there.

[00:24:30] Well, that's the cool thing about your program is once an owner submits the information, you're doing a lot of the background work and then it's copy-paste in the email. And then maybe a reminder three weeks later to copy-paste in the email, that kind of thing over and over again, which saves the owner a ton of time and effort. I had an owner in, where was she? I want to say Kentucky, but I know that's wrong. She's been super successful with like a dozen pairs. Wow. Increases.

[00:24:57] And interestingly, she said, did all of her work through email? Didn't have to get on a single phone call. I think she referenced how to win friends and influence people. Like the book, those tactics to be nice to people and get on a first name basis, remember their names and then ask other questions that show that you're interested. That was super helpful. Have you mentioned phone calls? Are there times in which you recommend a phone call or do you just simply focus on emails most of the time?

[00:25:24] I would agree most of our interactions are emails, which again, lowers the barrier. There are some where you're required to get on a phone call or Zoom to sort of like make your case verbally, in which case we tell our practices, just open your letter and just read it. But I definitely agree what we have seen is that's what I was saying about the adversary. If you can become friends with the network manager, it does help because they have to internally be able to defend the case that they're making.

[00:25:54] And folks are more likely to go out on a limb, stick their neck out there for someone that they are just like as an individual or they believe in the work that they're doing. And so I do think that that matters. Really cool. How have you seen this affect the owners that are doing it? Not all of them are successful. Some of them are.

[00:26:14] But have you seen a change in attitude or character related to how they perceive the insurance payers or frankly in their ability to approach them? Yeah. It's been a couple of things. One is it certainly creates a sense of relief that they have taken this off their to-do list because for years they've, I really should be doing that. And now you can say confidently, I have a great letter and I've used the best contacts that can be found.

[00:26:42] And so I can at least check it off my list. For those that have received increases, the financial impact is substantial because it's straight to the bottom line. Like this is just immediate increase in profits, you know, increase in dollar per visit times number of visits. And so there is some element of there's definitely a financial strength to it. But then there is some element of just like control that owners feel like, wait a minute, like I can actually negotiate and potentially win. It's no longer like I'm stuck in this system and there's nothing I can do about it.

[00:27:09] And I have seen it sort of emboldens practice owners to do things like go out of network, drop certain payers because they're like, you know what? Like I am going to, I can, I have an agency here. I can take action. That's been great. And then maybe the last one just to add is I view this as a form of advocacy for the industry. Each request documents reimbursement and access pressures. It makes practices concerns more visible.

[00:27:37] There are payers that when they respond to us, they're like, I didn't really know. I haven't really thought of my pelvic network before. And so there is just a version of by getting it out there, by sending these letters, like we are supporting the entire industry. And I do think that these individual requests can influence the broader behavior. And so my hope is that in time, this is something every practice owner does. Negotiate your rates every one or two years with some emails and some follow-ups and you can kind of get what you deserve.

[00:28:03] I like what you said about how that can help the industry, because I'm sitting here thinking if owners are quiet about this and they're too busy, they don't have the time or don't have the energy to really do a lot of this. And it's quiet on the payer network person, right? Who negotiates all these contracts. If she or he's not hearing from the owners on a regular basis, then they're just thinking everything's hunky dory.

[00:28:31] Like everyone's happy with their reimbursements and I can just focus on this other area. Whereas if they were flooded with a bunch of negotiation requests, now they're saying, oh, maybe there's a problem here. Maybe there is a concern that I need to be aware of. And at that point, it's kind of like the squeaky wheel gets the grease, right? Sure. But if everyone's quiet, then that doesn't do any benefit for us as an industry. I do.

[00:28:58] I can't draw an exact like core causation or correlation here, but we have had some payers where we have sent 25, 30 letters to the same contact. And we have seen at least for one pair, I know of certainly that at the beginning of receiving the letters, we were getting consistent no's. And now we are getting consistent yeses. And I do think that the pressure of all of these practices sharing independently, like this isn't a collusion effort. I know folks are really afraid of that word.

[00:29:28] This is just a tool that you can use to write a letter and send an email. This isn't like some, you know, coordinated effort. But when enough people send an email saying, hey, I'm dissatisfied, which is simply just an accurate reflection of the sentiment of practice owners. This isn't some like concocted game plan. It's just let them know your value. Let them know your frustration. I think that is something that it's just beneficial, I think, for practice owners across the industry. Can I express one concern and you can shoot it down if it's not? Yeah.

[00:29:57] So you're leveraging AI and leveraging also a lot of the same information no matter where there might be. But if you're going to the same payer in the same templated format of a letter, are the payers getting close to that and thinking, oh, this is just another letter that Brace Health helped XYZ owner create? Yeah. We've talked about this internally. Each letter is quite different because it's specific to the practice. So no argument is the same.

[00:30:24] It's very much tailored to the specific practice that we're working with. We have also started adjusting the formats so they look like different letters. They're so well written that I think most people now would say AI probably helped with that. But whether or not they're using the Brace Health tool or not, I don't think. We have yet to hear any. We've sent, like I said, dozens of letters to the same individuals.

[00:30:49] We've yet to hear it because at the end of the day, what you're ultimately, you're just making a case and saying you're threatening to go out of network. And like even if AI helped you with that, that's the fact of the matter. Like they have to respond to the way that, you know, to the statements that you're making. So how do you recommend Brace Health get started? And are there some metrics or reports that you recommend owners be better aware of for their individual practices as they start this process?

[00:31:18] Like I brought up the cost per visit as a key performance indicator that they should know if they're going to go into some kind of negotiation. Other reports or KPIs they recommend? Because I know some of those you're going to ask them to upload and share with you so you can provide the appropriate information. Yeah. So we don't ask for any of the information that you, so we don't ask for rates. And because that's all information that you will share. We just suggest a percentage increase request. And so we don't necessarily gather that information.

[00:31:48] So you're not necessarily gathering saying, you guys are currently paying me this amount. We recommend it go up 50%. Oh, you're not even working off that. That's interesting. Cool. No, because that. It can vary so much. It can vary a lot. And then I think that also, I don't think it actually necessarily helps the case. Like where you specifically are is, that's information the payer knows and has. What they might not understand is like what is the specific value that you bring.

[00:32:14] So in terms of like what I would gather before engaging, it is obviously your payer mix, the volume you have for each of these payers. You get a general sense for that. What are the specialties that you are offering that others are not offering? Like you can go on Google Maps and see this, or we can look it up for you. Anything that would make your practice specifically unique to a payer, that is what we encourage to collect. We usually don't gather anything around like practices, operational metrics or rates at first.

[00:32:44] We usually just say, give us some context on your practice and we'll write a letter for you. And what are some of, I'm assuming when you send follow-up letters or counter offers, you have a method to that madness as well? Not as much. I mean, it's more a, you know, you make the ask for some increase. Like we talked about, you know, we usually shoot for something like 50% just so we don't cap ourselves.

[00:33:10] When they come back with a response, it's either a no or it's an increase by a certain percentage. And then we ask for, it's sort of just linear from there. It's like, it's less scientific. The decision of whether you accept it, I think goes to what you're describing around cost per visit. And so let's say they're paying you 75 a visit and you're able to negotiate up to 85. Well, that's an exciting, you know, 12, 13% increase. But if your cost per visit's 91, you're losing money.

[00:33:37] So unless you're in network with that payer for some sort of mission-oriented reason or you're trying to drive patient volumes, it would make sense, I think, to reduce, especially if you have a wait list. You should be cutting that payer. So I think what you're suggesting is probably a sophistication level that we haven't found to be necessary quite yet. Just make the ask and make it to the right person. And that's what we've seen to be the results. But, you know, we're still early. We hope to send thousands of these letters. We only send a few hundred at this point. For sure.

[00:34:04] So if people go to bracehealth.com slash Nathan to sign up on the wait list and become a part of the free program, do they need to have any reports ready? Do you ask them for any specific information that they need to be prepared to upload? It'll be a five-minute survey that you could probably do on your phone as you're walking. So it's a very light touch. We used to have a longer intake process. But, again, that's just adding to the burden of doing this.

[00:34:30] So if you go to bracehealth.com slash Nathan, you'll get in because you're a referral from Nathan. And we'll get you that initial survey. It'll take, like I said, five minutes to fill out. And then you'll get a letter, an email to send, and then the specific contacts at the payers that you are in network with. And you just copy and paste, and you're on your way. Do you also do a short consultation with them during part of that process? Yep. I will. I'll usually meet with them as a way to sort of share, like, this is our understanding of the best arguments for your practice.

[00:35:00] We usually talk about if they've done anything in the past, as well as just set general expectations. There's some things that it's just better to talk through. Hey, you know, okay, we're working with United here. We've worked with this individual several times. This is what she's like, and this is what she cares about. This is the, you know. So some of that more, like, experience will we usually share. So we'll do a five-minute survey. We'll send you some information. Ten-minute call with me to give you a sense for what to expect. And then that's it. Well, you guys are an outsourced billing services company.

[00:35:29] How did you get into this little niche of negotiations? That's a great question. It started by just looking at our own customers' rates. We were like, these are very low for some of these payers. Have you tried negotiating? And they shared, no, not yet. And so as a team of software engineers building AI agents for making sure you get paid what you deserve, well, could we increase what you deserve was the question. So we sort of built this side tool. Like I said, we did those 10 initial negotiations, had four. Come back. We sort of expanded that to be a little bit larger.

[00:35:58] Saw that sort of 35% hit rate and said, you know, maybe there's something here. Right now we have an exclusive partnership with Nathan to get this in the hands of some practice owners. In time, we will probably charge for this. Or it's, you know, a product that we will offer. Or it's something that we'll just offer for our own customers on an annual basis. But for now, we're just learning. We're still trying to figure out, like, what works and what doesn't work. Gather that kind of national database that I've been talking about. That's sort of the stage we're in right now.

[00:36:26] So it's currently a great price if you come through with Nathan that might change over time. That's right. And you focus a lot on leveraging AI for this program. It sounds like you're doing a lot of AI integration into the billing and collection services that you provide as well. And I'm sure you're making great strides in that regard. Yeah, it's an amazing time to be building AI technology.

[00:36:48] And what we've seen is the ability to increase on the billing side practices revenue 2%, 3%, 4%, 5% without switching EMRs. By having each practice we work with gets a dedicated U.S. biller and a fleet of these AI agents that are making phone calls, checking portals, writing appeals letters. So you can imagine, you know, when you hire us, you're actually hiring one U.S.-based human and 1,000 these AI agents that are going to incessantly follow up to make sure you get paid what is needed.

[00:37:18] So we see that as like an extension of the work. Our ultimate mission is to strengthen private practices. And so that's where we're going towards. Well, that's super cool because I can easily see the connection between these letters that you're sending out for increasing reimbursement rates and appeals letters and dealing with insurance companies on a regular basis. Because you and I both know that the insurance companies are using a ton of AI agents. And if we're not combating with the same, then we're bringing a bunch of slings to a gunfight. It's exactly right.

[00:37:47] It's currently not a fair battle. We need to at least even the playing field with some of the technology that we're building. And especially as payers do more and more deny, delay, underpay, it's something like 60% of or 4% of denials get appealed and then 60% of the appeals get overturned. And so we need to be much more on top of like, did we, were we underpaid? Did we get paid what we expected? And it's not possible for a human to do. I started as a human. I was a biller for a handful of practices.

[00:38:16] That's how I learned. And I was missing things left, right, and center. When you're dealing with thousands of claims in a month, you're not going to be able to see all these issues. AI won't make those same mistakes. They will catch everything and they will follow up aggressively to make sure you get paid. That's so cool. Of course, people can go to bracehealth.com slash Nathan for the free program. If they wanted to talk to you about outsourced billing services, I'll get in touch with you guys. Shoot me an email, david at bracehealth.com.

[00:38:43] I am quite responsive on email, so you can get to me directly there. Or you can go to our website. We got a quick form on there to indicate your interests and I'll give you a call usually within a few minutes. I'm violently responsive to my phone. So feel free to reach out in either one of those ways. And thank you, Nathan, for the time today. As a listener to the podcast, I appreciate what you've been doing to spread great information out there. Thanks, man. It's great to have you on. Thanks for sharing as well and all that you're doing. Awesome.

[00:39:12] Thanks for listening to the Private Practice Owners Club. If you enjoyed this episode, would you mind doing us a huge favor and leaving a review? This helps us get the podcast out to more clinic owners to help them create greater freedom and profits so they can own their future. And visit our website, ppoclub.com, to find more resources and connect with us.