Ep 286: How to prevent osteoarthritis, with Dr Tarcisio de Campos
JOSPT InsightsOctober 26, 2026x
286
00:22:4220.78 MB

Ep 286: How to prevent osteoarthritis, with Dr Tarcisio de Campos

Osteoarthritis is common, and there's no cure for it. Clinicians working in musculoskeletal rehabilitation are likely to see people who are at risk of, or who have developed, osteoarthritis. In place of a cure, your focus might shift to strategies to reduce the risk of joint trauma—which could be the trigger for developing osteoarthritis years later—or to strategies that aim to slow the progression of the disease.

Dr Tarcisio de Campos—physiotherapist and Clinical Postdoctoral Research Fellow (Institute of Musculoskeletal Health, University of Sydney and Sydney Local Health District)—tackles the questions of which strategies should you choose and how effective are they?

------------------------------

RESOURCES

Interventions for preventing knee osteoarthritis: systematic review

OPTIKNEE 2022 consensus recommendations for improving knee health and preventing osteoarthritis

[00:00:00] I'm Danuja Aselan, Editor of the APTA Orthopedics Independent Study Courses, and I'm happy to announce that it's here. Current Concepts of Orthopedic Physical Therapy, the 6th Edition, is now available. This is the most rigorously peer reviewed edition yet. It's built to elevate your practice. You already know how important it is to stay current in your practice. Evidence evolves, best practices change, and your patients deserve the most up-to-date care you can give them. This is exactly what the 6th Edition was built for.

[00:00:27] There's 12 comprehensive sections covering every major body region from head to toe, all grounded in the latest evidence. Each section walks you through the anatomy, examination, diagnosis, and intervention, and wraps up with real-world case scenarios designed to sharpen your clinical reasoning so you can apply what you learn the moment you walk back to a clinic. Whether your patient's presentation is complex or not, Current Concepts gives you the evidence-based framework to examine more confidently, diagnostically, and

[00:00:57] diagnose more accurately, and treat more effectively. Also, if you're preparing for your OCS exam, this is your resource your peers have relied on for years to walk into the exam ready. Visit orthopt.org to register for the 6th Edition today. So the projection is that we're going to have an increase of 75% of cases of neobank or osteoarthritis.

[00:01:22] So currently, we have around just half a billion people, people who suffer from osteoarthritis, and that it's predicted to increase by around 650 million people globally by 2050. Hello, and welcome to JOSPT Insights, the podcast that aims to help you translate quality research to quality practice.

[00:01:51] I'm Claire Ardern, the Editor-in-Chief of the Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy. It's great to have you listening today. Working in musculoskeletal rehabilitation, chances are you'll work with people who are at risk of or who have developed osteoarthritis. OA is common, and there's no cure for it. So in place of a cure, your focus might shift to strategies to reduce the risk of joint trauma, which might be the trigger for osteoarthritis developing years later,

[00:02:21] or to strategies designed to slow the progression of the disease. Which strategies to choose, and how effective are they? These are two questions my guest tackles today. Dr. Tarsicio De Campos is a physiotherapist and clinical postdoctoral research fellow at the Institute for Musculoskeletal Health, which is a collaboration between the University of Sydney and Sydney Local Health District in Australia. Dr. De Campos works on ways of improving clinical services for people with musculoskeletal pain,

[00:02:51] including low back pain and osteoarthritis. Dr. Tarsicio De Campos, welcome to JOSPT Insights. Thanks, Claire, for having me. There's plenty of discussion in our broader musculoskeletal rehabilitation community about knee osteoarthritis. For a long time, we focused on how to manage OA. Today, we're focusing our attention a little bit earlier in the disease process, and you're going to talk us through where the research evidence is at for preventing knee osteoarthritis.

[00:03:20] Let's start with some of the strategies that have been advocated as potential ways to prevent osteoarthritis. What are they, and what's the rationale behind each of those strategies, Tarsy? We've done a kind of like examination or research the literature on prevention strategies, and we found that prevention strategy generally falls into two broad, I would say, buckets. So the first is the primary prevention.

[00:03:48] So those strategies that to prevent the disease or illness, like symptoms of pain, like pain, disability, quality of life, from initiating or in people at a health stage. Strategies that would prevent traumatic joint injured or obesity or muscle weakness. So those three actually are the highest in terms of risk for developing a knee-o-way or osteoarthritis condition there.

[00:04:17] And the second one is what I call secondary prevention. Strategies that are used to slow disease progression or delay the onset when people have that established condition there. So some strategies that would prevent recurrence or would prevent flares up. So those sort of strategies are also mentioned in the literature.

[00:04:40] I was very curious in running a systematic review, even though we have some literature showing that evidence. I was happy to actually put the systematic review together to understand, okay, what is up there in terms of robust evidence run by clinical trial designs. Your second question is, what's the rationale behind those? So if you look at primary prevention, so injury prevention strategies,

[00:05:09] so those are the ones who target acute joint trauma. Interventions, and it's actually well established in the literature with a few systematic review looking at that. So how can intervention strategies such as exercise education can actually reduce the incidence of trauma in your knee? Target exercise programs that include, for instance, neuromuscular exercise control.

[00:05:34] So strengthening programs has been shown quite effective, as I said, and reduce the risk of those injuries and potentially prevent the onset of future osteoarthritis. So I think, Tarsi, we're talking about primary prevention, so we're trying to stop the disease from happening in the first place effectively, or secondary, we're trying to stop flare-ups, ongoing symptoms,

[00:05:58] or at least reduce the burden of symptoms once someone has the established disease. Yes, that's correct. And another thing in terms of primary prevention, I would say like weight loss as well, it's established and we know that obese people, it's more likely to develop a knee-a-waste. So if you put in place a strategy to reduce or reduce weight in the population,

[00:06:27] that could potentially have a benefit of targeting knee-a-waste in the future. And also, if you have this population with the condition established, the knee-a-waste diagnosed there, you can actually apply those strategies to manage symptoms as well. And I think this is a really important distinction. Some of these strategies we're going to talk about in a moment might apply early or equally later on,

[00:06:56] so may apply before someone has a diagnosis of osteoarthritis or may apply later. And I think that's reflecting our contemporary understanding of osteoarthritis as not simply, quote, wear and tear on the joint, but a whole system, a systemic disease. And some of that will come through in some of the strategies we'll talk about. So I think that's the perfect segue into talking specifically about what you found in your systematic review.

[00:07:23] And you've recently published the systematic review in JOSPT Open. The link to the article is in the show notes for people who would like to have a deep dive into the article. And you've asked the question in this systematic review, how effective are interventions for primary or secondary prevention of osteoarthritis? What were the main findings, Tarsi? Before we jump to the main findings, it's important to kind of like set up this scene here.

[00:07:50] So when I look back at the, when I was actually looking at the literature and we look at the global part of disease study published in 2021. So the projection by 2005 is that we're going to have an increase of 75% of case of neobay or osteoarthritis. So currently we have around just half a billion people, people who suffer from osteoarthritis.

[00:08:18] And that it's predicted to increase by around 650 million people globally by 2050. So understanding prevention is crucial here. So we need to, to, to take action to start actually putting in place a strategy that would actually help people to prevent that.

[00:08:42] As we said, and it happens at first time, or if they have the condition established to prevent progression, or how can we actually help people to manage that condition? So we then put a group together and I would like to acknowledge all my colleagues. So from Brazil and also from America, Professor Mitch Wooden from Jamestown University,

[00:09:05] who helped us with this systematic review and a group from the University of São Carlos in Brazil that actually run the systematic review with me. We aim in this review to investigate. So what is up there in terms of prevention strategy, primary prevention and secondary prevention. And what we found was actually very little literature addressing that problem.

[00:09:31] So we only found five reports of three randomized controlled trials. So what we found then is that the current evidence is insufficient to support or to refuse the use of diet and exercise. So that was one of the, the arms from one study, one trial, the supplement of glucosamine, the combination of those interventions, diet and exercise with glucosamine,

[00:09:59] and the intra-articulitis preferring mean for actually reducing knee arthroplasty. There is uncertainty in those sort of interventions. But we found that when we combine self-management lifestyle strategy, that shows the strongest signal for prevention. Particularly in that study, they use prevention of symptoms of pain. That was a kind of like a secondary prevention because those people in that study,

[00:10:28] they have already osteoarthritis established, but they were asymptomatic at the point of entering into the study. And then they apply the intervention and see that that would reduce, reduce or decrease the risk of developing symptoms again in the future. The most compelling prevention and signal, particularly for the secondary prevention

[00:10:49] and in this high-risk group of women overweight, comes from that trial that investigate this multi-component intervention that combine diet and weight management with the structured exercise and education or prevention of symptomatic knee OA.

[00:11:11] So quite a global intervention you're talking about there, Tarsi, that I think has some strategies that we would recognize from some of the other guideline-recommended care for OA, the NICE guidelines, for example, or the many clinical guidelines that are out there. Yeah, that's actually aligned perfectly with, for instance, to 2023, Gibbs and colleagues.

[00:11:37] They actually, they observe across global clinical practice guidelines, and it's aligned perfectly with the findings that we've found in the systematic review that while passive or supplement-focused approach, lack robust support for prevention. So core lifestyle exercise education approach consistently form the, what I would say, the bedrock of evidence-informed care.

[00:12:04] Even though there is not a big number of studies, we can see clearly here that this is the direction to go. So people need to take that more active approach if we look at preventing knee osteoarthritis. I want to zero in on a couple of these buckets. You used buckets earlier on. I think that's a good term to use here. However, most of the strategies that are included in your systematic review, as you mentioned,

[00:12:32] a diet or supplement types of interventions, these are not typically in the direct remit of physiotherapists or of physical therapists. But I think it's reasonable to expect that patients might ask clinicians about something like glucosamine. Should I take glucosamine? Should I not? Or certainly you might consider weight management advice in your clinic. What advice do you have for our listeners today about how to talk with patients about these different options

[00:13:01] and how to integrate them into the types of conversations people are having in the clinic? Yeah, I guess that's something that happens daily in clinical practice. Like a patient comes to you and says, should I take glucosamine or chondroitin for my knee? While prescribing supplements isn't within direct physiotherapy scope, providing clear evidence-based guidance

[00:13:28] is 100% within our professional remit, I would say. I guess in those situations, I would say never dismiss the patients or make them feel foolish, I would say. So patients, they come and they ask about supplements because they try to actively take some approach for the joint because they're suffering there.

[00:13:54] You're daily kind of like bombarding with media showing that those supplements works. So I would say for them to share what systematic appraisers shows, clinicians could say that supplements are widely advertised but high quality international guidelines like the Gibbs one that I just mentioned who look at the guidelines globally

[00:14:23] and the other, the clinical case standard, which in Australia, they explicitly advise against rotine user glucosamine and chondroitin because large scale trials show there's no benefit when compared to placebo. So I would spend a little bit of the effort or redirect to what actually works and to get them engaged in more physical activity.

[00:14:51] Some of those, what we call a neuromuscular control training that actually help you to work in your joints, strengthening exercise that build up strength in your muscles. And we still need to understand actually what are the mechanisms who modulate pain when you're actually doing exercise. We know that it works, but the literature is still trying to understand, okay, how. Never dismiss the patient.

[00:15:18] Explain what its benefit, what it's proven that works, and redirect and shift the attention to those more active approach like exercise, education, and weight management. I like that approach a lot. So you're listening, you're validating that someone's pain is real, the symptoms are tough to deal with perhaps, and that you're here to work with the person to help them. There are options. Some of those options may be other than taking some of the supplements,

[00:15:45] which brings us perfectly to talking about neuromuscular training and education programs. You mentioned those sorts of programs, Tarsi, and listeners will know well the GLAD program, Good Living with Osteoarthritis Denmark. These are well established as effective for managing OA. Do you think we're better off focusing our attention on these programs, at least maybe for secondary prevention of OA? Yes, absolutely. I think that's the way to go.

[00:16:14] And we have actually evidence on those approach for primary prevention, as I said. Not directly studies having the osteoarthritis as an outcome, but those strategies to prevent, for instance, knee injury, after having those post-traumatic OA or post-traumatic injury, the likelihood for you to develop OA in the future, it's higher.

[00:16:41] So those approach, those neuromuscular control training, strengthening exercise, they work quite well. So we don't have well established studies, look at secondary preventions. And I strongly believe that that's the way to go. And it's, I actually would like to run a study on secondary prevention and look into that. There is a nice paper about how should we approach prevention,

[00:17:07] that we should approach it kind of like a lifespan prevention. So we should understand from the beginning at early stage, usually those people who have traumatic joint injury, they actually early on, like teenagers or early adulthood, they're engaged in physical activity sports. When those events happen, that could be the trigger point to potentially generate the issues in the future.

[00:17:34] So having those strategies in place at early stage, during the lifespan of the condition, it's important. I think we need to go and understand more. And again, those strategies, build a program, a strategy using those interventions, like neuromuscular training for early stage, near way what I would call early stage. So there's still a little bit of debate in the literature

[00:18:02] and how to diagnose those people. But I believe that should be something that we have to put some more efforts in getting to identify people at very early stage and start to engage them to those approach and how to self-manage those conditions. So I'm actually doing a systematic review at the moment, trying to understand the pattern of behavior of pain and dysfunction in people at early stage.

[00:18:32] Because I believe there's a lot of studies out there, but a nice inception cohort study looking at this pattern would be very informative for us then to implement and design intervention to target and modulate the pattern of pain as a short term and also how that would impact the long term in terms of developing or disease progression. I think that's something that we need to think about.

[00:19:02] This is great. We're getting two for the price of one. We're learning about a systematic review you've already conducted and learning about something that's on the horizon, Tarsi. This is wonderful. I suppose the other point to make about the neuromuscular training programs, particularly around secondary prevention of OA, is that there is some evidence to suggest that doing those programs can at least delay the need for a total joint replacement. We can debate whether that counts as secondary prevention, I suppose, but there is some evidence to suggest

[00:19:31] that they can have a meaningful effect on people's symptoms. The other point I'll make is I think it would be remiss if we didn't mention the OptiKnee group. There's a whole bunch of people who have been in this field doing loads of work for a really long time, and part of the OptiKnee work has been around looking at traumatic knee injury and then the relationship to developing osteoarthritis and what to do in that in-between time,

[00:19:58] which is where I think you're really focused on targeting too. The only challenge here is when we think about designing clinical trials, it can be quite expensive because sometimes you wait a long period of time to see actually something happen. So it's a slow and progressive condition. One thing that we can think about as we have a lot of observational data, so we could potentially have what we call those emulation trials

[00:20:28] where we'll try to emulate, use those observational data to emulate trials and see what sort of people are taking whatever intervention and compare to a group who are doing nothing or doing other interventions, and you try to emulate a trial. It's a more robust design, but you can actually put that and have some more insights what's going on with that population. There's lots going on

[00:20:57] and lots to look forward to in the future to help guide our practice as musculoskeletal rehabilitation clinicians. That's the message that we need to pass to clinicians and to patients who are listening to the podcast. So they have to shift sometimes their mind, be more active, engage in physical exercise at early stage. Because if we leave that late on, it can be too late.

[00:21:26] I think one thing that would be nice to say is that the approach should be target upstream, not mid and downstream. Because if we get that upstream early on, early stage, it's more likely that you actually educate people and they know what to do in the future. I'm grateful to you and the team for a robust systematic review to at least give us a starting point to help us see what do we know now and what might we need

[00:21:54] to better understand in the future. Dr. Tarsicio de Campos, thanks for joining me today on JOSPT Insights. Nice to be with you, Claire. Thanks so much. Thanks for listening to this episode of JOSPT Insights. For more discussion of the issues in musculoskeletal rehabilitation that are relevant to your practice, subscribe to JOSPT Insights wherever you get your podcasts. And while you're there, feel free to leave us a review.

[00:22:24] They all help. If you like JOSPT Insights, help others to find us. And to keep up to date with all the latest JOSPT content, make sure you're subscribed across all our social media channels. We'll talk with you next time.